OK, my agent didn’t
make me do anything.
Yet as the
publishing world changes, agents are increasingly taking on some of the role
that used to belong solely to editors. Many agents now provide editing advice
for clients before submitting the book for publication.
When I first met my
agent, Katherine Cowles, she said, “I love your book, I can sell your book. No
problem.” Of course, that was music to my ears, having slaved over it in
obscurity for many many years. I was ecstatic, actually. She was the first
agent I’d approached, and she was certain she could place my book at a top
publishing house! In my delirium, I scarcely noticed when at the very end of
our first meeting, she added kind of casually, “I’m thinking, though, that you
need to cut down a few sections. I’ll send you my ideas for that in an email.”
I nodded gamely: sure, I could trim a
few sections, no problem.
A couple of days
later, I got an email outlining her suggested edits. At first it didn’t look
like a lot, maybe 5 or 6 numbered items. But once I started reading I went into
shock – if I followed her suggestions, I’d be cutting 120 pages from my book!
Mostly through cutting out entire chapters or scenes. I was stunned. She called
me on the phone a few minutes after I got the email. I guess she anticipated
that I might be slightly hysterical. She told me firmly, “This is how I’m going
to sell your book, Christina. Once you have an editor, you can always talk to
him or her about putting this material back in. I’m not your editor – I just
want to make sure we get your manuscript read.”
I decided to trust
her. She knew the business after all – I knew nothing about it. And now that
she’d pointed it out, I could see how potential publishers might be daunted by a
600 page manuscript from a completely unknown writer – a manuscript so huge it
had to be bound into two volumes.
I jumped in and
worked incredibly fast. I didn’t do the cuts exactly as my agent specified –
and she was fine with that – but I did cut about 120 pages, working night and
day. There are tons of continuity problems that crop up when you start making
cuts on that scale. You have to find every single place that material might
have been referred to later in the book. It’s a nightmare. I was in tears by
the end of the first day of editing, not just because of all the continuity
problems I was facing, but also because it was heartbreaking to lose some of my
favorite parts of the book. “She might as well have asked me to cut off my
arm!” I wailed to my boyfriend. But interestingly enough, almost all the
material she had picked for the cutting room floor was very old, from when the
novel had a different narrator and point of view, material that I was so loathe
to lose that I’d tried to force it into the book’s new structure. It didn’t
really work – and being a sharp reader, she’d picked up on that.
It was extremely
painful at first. I started calling my new manuscript “The Tricking of Freya Lite.” But true to her word, in a very
short time my agent had me signing a contract with a major publisher. By the
time I was at the editorial stage with my editor, I didn’t even mention to him
the idea of reincorporating the 120 pages from the cutting room floor. I could
see that the book was probably… I hesitate to say “stronger without it,” even
now. I still love that lost material. But the book is definitely a better read.
It was a smart
decision on my agent’s part. And true to her word, she never made any further
editorial suggestions for my book. She left that to me and my actual editor.
I’m secretly
considering using some of that lost material in my next novel – but knowing my
agent, she’ll probably want to cut it out of that book too.